The emergency or ‘particular adjustment’ funds tabled by Finance Minister Tito Mboweni on June 24 centred on the possibly disastrous trajectory of South Africa’s fiscal affairs.

It could simply be summarised in two charts and an extract from the foreword of the Supplementary Funds Evaluate Doc:

“For a number of years, the Nationwide Treasury has been warning that an absence of fiscal area would depart South Africa susceptible to exterior shocks. That threat is now a actuality … South Africa has begun heading right into a debt spiral.”

Supply: Nationwide Treasury

The above mirror how South Africa shall be caught in a debt entice if authorities doesn’t actively put measures in place to lower authorities expenditure and improve financial exercise.

If authorities is to proceed on the present trajectory, debt-to-GDP might attain 140%. With spiralling debt, the debt service price will improve exponentially, ultimately leading to South Africa defaulting on its debt.

The main focus ought to nevertheless not be on what was stated within the funds speech, however relatively on what was left unsaid.

Improve taxes

Mboweni alluded to tax will increase of R5 billion in 2021/22, R10 billion in 2022/23, R10 billion in 2023/24 and R15 billion in 2024/25, however with no point out of how this shall be achieved.

The truth that no tax coverage bulletins have been made signifies that Treasury requires extra time to ponder these adjustments. Apparently, the R5 billion determine might simply be achieved by bracket creep alone. Taxpayers have to attend till subsequent yr to see precisely how Treasury expects to gather extra tax income.

There was an excessive amount of hypothesis within the media on the introduction of a so-called wealth tax, however the feasibility of a wealth tax in South Africa would should be investigated.


Elevating income by way of a wealth tax is clutching at straws
Coronavirus: Why South Africa wants a wealth tax now

The viability of a wealth tax relies on the quantity of tax that may be collected versus the price of its administration. Critics of a wealth tax argue that it might be too pricey and complicated to implement. It appears Treasury agrees.


No point out was product of the Nationwide Well being Insurance coverage (NHI) and its introduction. The price of placing this in place within the present financial surroundings makes it untenable.

Learn: NHI advantages and implementation stay undiagnosed

Treasury appears to have positioned NHI on the back-burner till South Africa has weathered the Covid-19 storm and is ready to reveal constant and dependable development.

Illicit economic system

The lack of tax income as a result of tobacco and alcohol ban has been immense.

Many commentators are calculating R1.5 billion per 30 days misplaced in sin tax assortment alone.

Alternatively, the illicit economic system has flourished. Within the February Funds Speech, Mboweni said that the South African Income Service (Sars) would “renew its deal with illicit and felony exercise”. Nonetheless, it may very well be argued that the lockdown has strengthened the illicit economic system, with Sars powerless to intervene.

Treasury must deal with the tax income already misplaced in addition to the income that may maintain being misplaced if the illicit economic system continues to develop.

The upside

Happily, this newest funds was not all doom and gloom. Treasury acknowledged financial reform targeted on the underlying construction of the economic system.

Primarily, it goals to scale back the price of doing enterprise, taking steps to enhance the competitiveness of the economic system by lowering the dominance of state-owned firms in community industries, and supporting new and current sectors with large-scale job creation potential.

Tertius Troost is tax supervisor at Mazars.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *